PC, M.D.: How Political Correctness Is Corrupting Medicine.
     
American Enterprise Institute.
American Enterprise Institute.
 
Brainwashed: The Seductive Appeal of Mindless Neuroscience

Now Available:
BRAINWASHED:
The Seductive Appeal of Mindless Neuroscience

By Sally Satel and Scott O. Lilienfeld

June 4, 2013, Basic Books

What can’t neuroscience tell us about ourselves? Since fMRI—functional magnetic resonance imaging— was introduced in the early 1990s, brain scans have been used to help politicians understand and manipulate voters, determine guilt in court cases, and make sense of everything from musical aptitude to romantic love. Although brain scans and other neurotechnologies have provided groundbreaking insights into the workings of the human brain, the increasingly fashionable idea that they are the most important means of answering the enduring mysteries of psychology is misguided—and potentially dangerous.

In Brainwashed, psychiatrist and AEI scholar Sally Satel and psychologist Scott O. Lilienfeld reveal how many of the real-world applications of human neuroscience gloss over its limitations and intricacies, at times obscuring—rather than clarifying—the myriad factors that shape our behavior and identities. As Satel and Lilienfeld explain, this “neurocentric” view of the mind risks undermining our most deeply held ideas about selfhood, free will, and personal responsibility, putting us at risk of making harmful mistakes, whether in the courtroom, interrogation room, or addiction treatment clinic.

A provocative account of our obsession with neuroscience, Brainwashed brilliantly illuminates what contemporary neuroscience and brain imaging can and cannot tell us about ourselves, providing a much-needed reminder about the many factors that make us who we are.

Brainwashed was a finalist for the 2013 Los Angeles Times Book Prize in Science.

Advance Praise:

“Modern brain science is an exhilarating frontier of human knowledge, but many of its champions have gotten carried away. This book shows how attempts to explain the human condition by pointing to crude blotches of brain activity may be superficially appealing, but they are ultimately unsatisfying. Sally Satel and Scott Lilienfeld are not dualists, romantics, mystics, or luddites. Their case for understanding human affairs at multiple levels of analysis will resonate with many thoughtful psychologists and biologists, and they make that case lucidly, expertly, and entertainingly. Anyone who is interested in the brain—and who isn’t?—will be enlightened by this lively yet judicious critique.

—Steven Pinker Harvard College Professor and Johnstone Family Professor in the Department of Psychology at Harvard University

“In this smart, provocative and very accessible book, Satel and Lilienfeld are not out to bury neuroscience; they are here to save it—to rescue it from those who have wildly exaggerated its practical and theoretical benefits. Some of this book is very funny, as when they review the dubious history of neuromarketing and neuropolitics, and some of it is dead serious, as in their discussion of how the abuse of neuroscience distorts criminal law and the treatment of addicts. Brainwashed is essential reading for anyone who wants to understand the use and abuse of one of the most important scientific developments of our time.

—Paul Bloom, Professor of Psychology and Cognitive Science at Yale and author of How Pleasure Works

“Satel and Lilienfeld have produced a remarkably clear and important discussion of what today’s brain science can and cannot deliver for society. As a neuroscientist, I confess that I also enjoyed their persuasive skewering of hucksters whose misuse of technology in the courtroom and elsewhere is potentially damaging not only to justice but also to the public understanding of science.”

—Dr. Steven E. Hyman, Director of the Stanley Center for Psychiatric Research at the Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard and Former Director of the National Institute of Mental Health

“An authoritative, fascinating argument for the centrality of mind in what, doubtless prematurely, has been called the era of the brain.”

—Peter D. Kramer, author of Listening to Prozac

“There is a widespread belief that brain science is the key to understanding humanity and that imaging will X-ray our minds, revealing why we buy things and whether we are telling the truth and answering questions about addiction, criminal responsibility, and free will. Brainwashed is a beautifully written, lucid dissection of these exaggerated claims, informed by a profound knowledge of current neuroscience. It is essential reading for anyone who wants a balanced assessment of what neuroscience can and cannot tell us about ourselves.”

—Raymond Tallis, author of Aping Mankind: Neuromania

“Brainwashed provides an engaging and wonderfully lucid tour of the many areas in which the progress and applications of neuroscience are currently being overstated and oversold. Some of the hyping of neuroscience appears fairly harmless, but more than a little of it carries potential for real damage—especially when it promotes erroneous ideas about addiction and criminal behavior. The book combines clearheaded analysis with telling examples and anecdotes, making it a pleasure to read.”

—Hal Pashler, Distinguished Professor of Psychology and Cognitive Science, University of California, San Diego

When Altruism Isn't Enough

When Altruism Isn't Enough: The Case for Compensating Kidney Donors

Edited by Sally Satel, M.D.

AEI Press (Washington) January 2009

When Altruism Isn't Enough argues that compensating people who donate an organ to a desperate stranger-an extraordinary act of live-saving value-will motivate others to do the same, increase the national supply of kidneys, and reduce needless death and suffering. It is the first book to describe in detail how a government-regulated, compensation-based system for living donors could be designed. Contributors to the volume-physicians, legal scholars, economists, and philosophers-set the stage for reform of NOTA by showing how compensating donors would be ethically permissible, economically justifiable, and pragmatically achievable.    More . . .

The Health Disparities Myth.

The Health Disparities Myth: Diagnosing the Treatment Gap

By Sally Satel, M.D. and Jonathan Klick

AEI Press (Washington) January 2006

Two fifty-year-old men arrive at an emergency room with acute chest pain. One is white and the other black. Will they receive the same quality of treatment and have the same chance of recovery? Many experts today insist that their race will profoundly affect how the medical-care system deals with them, and that the black patient will get much inferior care. Is this true? The Health Disparities Myth critically assesses recent research bearing on this question.   More . . .

One Nation Under Therapy : How the Helping Culture is Eroding Self-Reliance.

One Nation Under Therapy : How the Helping Culture is Eroding Self-Reliance

By Christina Hoff Sommers and Sally Satel

St. Martin’s Press (April 1, 2005

More >>

PC, M.D.: How Political Correctness Is Corrupting Medicine.

PC, M.D. How Political Correctness is Corrupting Medicine

By Sally Satel, M.D.

Basic Books (October 2001)

Reviews

Introduction

Critical Acclaim

“Most impressive. Satel explodes myths that are hindering research funding and preventing Americans from getting the quality of care they deserve. Satel is helping steer medicine back to the goal of serving the patient's needs and restoring health through science. PC, M.D. is essential reading for healthcare consumers.”

—ELIZABETH WHELAN, Ph.D., MPH, President, American Council on Science and Health

"While the nation has been preoccupied with headline-grabbing subjects like HMO’s, Medicare, and the millions of uninsured Americans—all pressing issues indeed—tbe ‘indoctrinologists’ have swooped in under the radar. And their prescriptions—which ultimately are not about health, but rather about narrow ideas of social justice—will be hazardous to our health."

This is Sally Satel’s opening salvo in her brilliantly waged war against the forces of political correctness. Drawing on a wealth of information, much of it never revealed before, PC, M.D. documents for the first time what happens when the tenets of political correctness—including victimology, multiculturalism and the rejection of fixed truths and individual autonomy—are allowed to enter the fortress of medicine. Consider these examples:

  • A professor at the Harvard School of Public Health teaches her students that racial discrimination causes high blood pressure among blacks—an unsubstantiated and dangerous "truth."
  • Former psychiatric patients, calling themselves "consumer-survivors," condemn the health care system for violating their human rights. They are on a crusade to "limit the powers of psychiatry by making consumers full partners in diagnosis and treatment."
  • Nurses charge that they are so oppressed by the male-dominated medical system that they can't give their patients optimal care.

The consequences of putting politics before health are far-reaching, argues Satel. It wastes taxpayer money on bogus research and diverts resources that could be used to discover authentic causes of suffering, provide proven therapies, and rigorously investigate new ones. PC, M.D. is a powerful wake-up call to the medical profession and to patients, who are the ultimate victims of these disturbing trends.

Recent Articles Subscribe

Should e-cigarettes be taxed? by Sally Satel, Alan D. Viard, and Alex Brill On the Margin | April 14, 2014

Wall Street Is Not a Death Trap Bloomberg | March 31, 2014

Descendant of Fear: On Scott Stossel's My Age of Anxiety The Millions | March 5, 2014

How e-cigarettes could save lives The Washington Post | February 14, 2014

Where Was I? 'The Answer to the Riddle Is Me' and 'I Forgot to Remember' New York Times | February 14, 2014

Breaking the Bond of Heroin and Painkillers Bloomberg | February 6, 2014

Clear the air on addiction The Globe and Mail | January 31, 2014

Friday Feedback: Solutions for the Psych Bed Shortage? MedPage Today | January 31, 2014

Are Hollywood Starlets Glamorizing Smoking By Using E-Cigarettes? Forbes | January 23, 2014

Organ Donors Save Lives Act of 2013 Statement Before the Council of the District of Columbia, Committee on Finance and Revenue | January 13, 2014

MORE >>

Brainwashed:
The use and misuse of neuroscience

Sally Satel and Scott Lilienfeld in conversation with David Brooks

Sally Satel and Scott Lilienfeld in conversation with David Brooks
WATCH >>
 
After Words: Michael Gazzaniga, "Who's in Charge?: Free Will and the Science of the Brain,"
hosted by Sally Satel, BookTV.org

Satel on BookTV.
WATCH >>
 

Compensating Organ Donors:
Sally Satel joins The Agenda to make the economic case for donor incentives.

 
C-SPAN: Sally Satel and Nick Schulz discuss the organ donor shortage in the United States.
Satel on CSPAN.
WATCH >>
 
Sally Satel discusses PC, M.D.
Satel on Booknotes.
WATCH >>
   

[About the Author] [Articles] [Congressional Testimony]
[American Enterprise Institute] [Author Bio] [Contact] [Home]